HomeHeard it on the ShowThe Top 5 Easter Candies in AmericaThe Top 5 Easter Candies in AmericaMon, April 10, 2017 by Tessa Snyder SHARE NOW 5. Peeps 4. Hershey’s Eggs 3. Jelly Beans 2. Chocolate Bunnies 1. Reese’s Peanut Butter Eggs Listen to Murphy Sam and Jodi: On Demand And while you’re at it… leave a comment and follow us on Facebook, Twitter & Instagram and subscribe to our YouTube channel.